The vanity is the piece of furniture a bathroom is used around: where hands get washed, teeth get brushed and everything gets put down. Replacing a dated or water-damaged one changes the room more than almost anything else short of a full remodel.
It looks like a simple swap. What decides whether it stays simple is measuring properly, keeping the plumbing where it is, and knowing what the floor and wall look like under the old one.
Measuring the space
Vanities come in common widths, from narrow units for a powder room up to long double-sink vanities. Measuring the space means more than the width of the old cabinet:
- The clear width between walls, or between a wall and a tub or toilet, leaving room at the sides.
- Clearance to the toilet. Building codes set a minimum distance from the center of the toilet to the side of a vanity, so a wider vanity cannot simply push closer to it.
- Depth, and the walkway left in front. A standard-depth vanity in a narrow bathroom can make the room feel cramped; shallower vanities exist for that reason.
- Door swing, both the bathroom door and the vanity doors and drawers, which need room to open past the toilet and the trim.
A double vanity needs real width. Two sinks squeezed into too short a counter leave no space to put anything down, and many people find one sink with a long counter more useful.
Standard height or comfort height
Older vanities were often built lower than kitchen counters. Many newer vanities are taller, closer to kitchen counter height, which saves bending for most adults. A vessel sink sits on top of the counter, so it is usually paired with a lower vanity to bring the rim back to a comfortable height. Whoever uses the bathroom most, including children, is worth thinking about here.
Freestanding or wall-mounted
- A freestanding vanity sits on the floor like a cabinet, with a toe kick or legs. It offers the most storage and hides the plumbing completely.
- A wall-mounted or floating vanity is hung on the wall with the floor running underneath. It makes a small bathroom look bigger and makes cleaning the floor easier. The wall needs solid backing behind it to carry the vanity, the top and someone leaning on it, which usually means opening the wall to add blocking between the studs.
With a floating vanity, the drain and supply lines may be visible below it, so their height and finish matter more.
Tops and sinks
- An integrated top, where the counter and sink are molded as one piece in cultured marble, solid surface or similar materials, has no seam around the sink and is easy to clean.
- A stone or quartz top with an undermount sink looks more substantial and is cut to fit the vanity and the room.
- A vessel sink sits on top of the counter and makes a statement, but splashes more and needs a tall faucet or a wall-mounted one.
How quartz, granite, solid surface and laminate compare is covered in kitchen countertops compared, and the same trade-offs apply in a bathroom, where heat matters less and water matters more.
Faucet holes
The top has to be drilled for the faucet you choose. Single-hole faucets need one hole; centerset faucets have handles and spout on one base across three closely spaced holes; widespread faucets have separate handles further apart. A wall-mounted faucet needs no holes in the top but needs plumbing inside the wall, which turns a vanity swap into a bigger job. The faucet is chosen before the top is ordered or cut.
Keep the plumbing where it is
Choosing a vanity that works with the existing drain and supply lines is the biggest saving available. Moving a drain means opening the wall or floor and re-running the line at the correct slope. Drawer layouts matter too: drawers under the sink have to clear the drain trap, which is why many vanities have a false front or U-shaped drawers in that spot.
Old shutoff valves under a sink are often stiff or no longer close fully, and replacing them while the vanity is out is a small cost that avoids a problem later. The plumbing connections are made by a licensed plumber, and a double vanity where there was a single one needs a second drain and supply.
The floor under the old vanity
In many bathrooms the flooring was installed around the old vanity, not under it. If the new vanity has a different footprint, or is wall-mounted, the bare subfloor or a patch of older flooring is suddenly exposed. Before ordering, it is worth knowing what is under the old one: either choose a new vanity that covers the same footprint, or plan to replace the floor at the same time.
The subfloor under a vanity is also where slow leaks from a drain or supply line show up. Soft or stained subfloor is cut out and replaced before the new vanity goes in.
Tile floors are often run under a new vanity, while floating floors stop at it, for the same reasons covered in kitchen flooring: under the cabinets or around them? If the floor is being heated, the heating is kept out from under the vanity, as covered in heated tile floors.
The wall behind it
Taking out an old vanity usually reveals unpainted wall, holes from the old fastenings, and sometimes damage from a glued-on backsplash. The wall is repaired and painted before the new vanity goes in, rather than painting around it afterward. The joint between the top and the wall, and any side splash, is sealed with a flexible sealant so water cannot run down behind the vanity.
Mirror, lights and outlets
A wider or narrower vanity often means the mirror, medicine cabinet and lights over it no longer line up. Lights on either side of a mirror give more even light on a face than a single fixture above. Bathroom outlets need ground-fault protection under the electrical code, and any new lighting or outlet work is done by a licensed electrician while the wall is open.
Material and moisture
Bathrooms are humid, and the vanity sits right where water splashes. Solid wood and plywood construction hold up better to occasional water than particleboard, which swells if water gets into a cut edge. A bathroom fan sized for the room and ducted outside protects the vanity as much as the paint and grout. Wipe up standing water at the back of the counter rather than letting it sit against the sealant.
A swap or part of a remodel
A straight vanity replacement, with the plumbing staying where it is, is a short job. When the floor, tile or shower are changing too, the vanity goes in near the end, after the tile has cured, as laid out in bathroom remodel: the order of work. Custom vanities and stone tops have lead times, so they are ordered before work starts.
Planning a new vanity
Vanities and their tops are part of our room remodels, along with the flooring, tile, trim and paint, with plumbing and electrical carried out by licensed trades we bring in. One written fixed-price scope covers the room, and every project carries our lifetime workmanship warranty. Book a free in-home estimate and we will measure the bathroom and look at what the old vanity is sitting on.